Maximizing Growth: Annuities vs. CD Accounts

Financial planning tools for investment decisions

A Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) can be a strong alternative to a bank Certificate of Deposit (CD), particularly for conservative savers who want predictable growth without market risk. Like a CD, a MYGA offers a guaranteed interest rate for a set period — often 3, 5, or 7 years. But where it can pull ahead is in both growth efficiency and tax treatment.

From a growth standpoint, MYGAs are often able to higher fixed rates than comparable CDs. In addition, MYGAs typically allow interest to compound without interruption, which can enhance overall accumulation during the guarantee period.

The real advantage, however, is tax deferral. CD interest is taxable each year as it is credited, whether you withdraw it or not. That means you’re paying taxes annually on growth you may not even be using. With a MYGA, interest grows tax-deferred. You do not owe taxes until you withdraw the funds. This allows the full amount of your interest to continue compounding year after year. Over time, that tax deferral can create a meaningful difference in total accumulation, especially for individuals in higher tax brackets.

There is also an element of planning flexibility. With CDs, you are often limited to shorter terms and face penalties for early withdrawal. MYGAs typically offer structured surrender schedules but may include annual penalty-free withdrawal provisions. In addition, beneficiaries of a MYGA receive the account value directly, avoiding probate delays in many cases, depending on how it is structured.

For conservative investors who want principal protection, guaranteed growth, and improved tax efficiency, a MYGA can serve as a more strategic alternative to traditional bank CDs. The key is matching the term length and liquidity features to your specific needs, but when positioned properly, a MYGA can deliver both steadier accumulation and smarter tax treatment.ay informed and proactive. Whether you choose annuities or CD accounts, the key is to make decisions that support your long-term financial health.